Ngrok Not Working

ngrok, localhost, make localhost online. Here are some links to interesting web pages which I have encountered. Each one is a little different in set up but do work the same in principle. If not, note the port it runs on and stop debugging. I thought this was supposed to provide ngrok as the link but as you said if you provide IP then you get IP as the trackers not working. Your localhost server on its own will not work. it will not work offline…If I want to access the manifest file via HTTPS, I will need a valid certificate. com) has published an article entitled 'How to steal millions in chump change' which was about online credit card theft!. Step 2: Conveyor is automatically enabled for web application projects, run (debug) a project and note the Remote URL, that is the URL you will use from your device or other computer. The same but different posed questions regarding how to return a valid MySQL date equivalent to "Next Monday" given any particular day, as determined by MySQL's CURDATE(). Download the latest version of Erlang from here. Remotely access your Raspberry Pi from anywhere in the world via your web browser without DynDNS, VPN, Static IP or Port Forwarding. Is there an easy fix for that besid. 4 Supported Operating Systems The Framework should run on almost any Unix-based operating system that. For more information about Minikube, see the proposal. io, and tries to connect to the dev server directly. To improve your experience, we use cookies to remember log-in details and provide secure log-in, collect statistics to optimize site functionality, and deliver content tailored to your interests. The relevant part of the bash man page says:. 11 - Fix ngrok installer after ngrok download page changed. If installing using RVM be warned that symlinks will not work do to the way it places the binary stubs of the metasploit-framework gem. You can see servers are getting request and post it. Apache Subversion (often abbreviated SVN, after its command name svn) is a software versioning and revision control system distributed as open source under the Apache License. But there is also a free model. Before Chrome 32, Notification. Like Apache, NGINX can serve HTML files over HTTP, and with additional modules can serve dynamic web pages using scripting languages such as PHP. but in kibana i still does not see parsing result system (system) closed June 16, 2017, 1:38pm #12 This topic was automatically closed 28 days after the last reply. Rave react native SDK. Push it up to your fork and then submit a Pull Request to this repo. How to Install Node. Like most developers, I work locally. So you're bored during your free period at school and want to browse Facebook. Web development moves fast. Get your free domain name today, before it's gone. It’s working, but I’ve little issues: I set the interval to 12000, both t and h. NOOK for Windows 10 (Windows), free and safe download. How to Install Node. But sadly it did not work. Re: in final lab - my ngrok io url is not working Joe_Scanlon Feb 1, 2018 3:53 PM ( in response to Marcelo Jabali-Oracle ) That was it - thanks!!. js app But the concept is working already,now we should be able to use other standard. Rave react native SDK. The primary advantage of Serveo over ngrok is the use of your existing SSH client, so there's no client application to install. If your DDNS address is not working correctly it is now recommended to raise a Technical Support Request and a member of the LILIN Technical Support Team will contact you as soon as possible. Based on your post, that Forbidden is being returned by ngrok, not by PythonAnywhere, so you should work out why the ngrok is returning a 403. Webhooks require a publicly accessible endpoint (localhost alone will not work). This works – until one is so bold as to click any link, which go to https:// URLs. The address to access it from the internet would be the one next to Forwarding, with the ngrok domain. The new MSIX isntaller/package format looks very promising, and, in particular provides “isolated” app installation, making sure it stores its files only in predefined places on disk, and registry changes are virtualized as well. In this quick tutorial by Phil Leggetter, we’ll cover how you can both send and receive SMS from your Laravel application. For instance, if you want to ssh from office back to home, you need to go into home router settings first, and set up port forwarding for port 22 to a specific IP address on your home network and port number, in your case 192. Building Python web apps with Flask DISCLAIMER: In the time since this post was published, the Spotify API changed to no longer allow unauthorized requests. Then I created a windows payload on kali linux with LHOST=(ngrok ip, got it from pinging the ngrok address) and LPORT=4444. Have you been frustrated by the default window shell settings of Git Bash under Windows? I have. in the background) and without user intervention. The Global Cloud Platform Trusted by over 20 million Internet properties. 3) Tick the box for Share this folder and then please make sure the the Share name is correct. But am still going to provision for it here. you can use 8888. Pull requests 8. We appreciate it!. Make sure your ngrok server is working and Python script also running otherwise it will not work. 97 to work's VPN, I'm able to ping but when I use the public xFinity wifi it indicates that the tunnel is up but I can't ping the internal hosts of my VPN. Hello, I started the server on my computer, but it is not accessible from a non-local area network. Most query endpoints support both the created_at_min and updated_at_min filter parameters. The router says the port is open but my device is not allowing any. io", not "https://1a2b3c4d. How do I fix this?. Other at JIO network level Try connecting to the open port from some other. Terminal command will not execute after boot what you expected to happen and how you know it's not working. js < /dev/null &'. ngrok secure introspectable tunnels to localhost webhook development tool and debugging tool. Localhost at port 19002 doesn't work. Minecraft) The easiest program to use, in my experience, is ngrok. I'm pining a Rasa server through Ngrok and postman is working fine. exe -V and looking for a value labelled as HTTPD_ROOT. 1 applications. In this guide, we'll use a brand new Developer Edition of Salesforce. Or the question is not even asked and the assumption is that somehow the combination of JDeveloper and Git does not work well. IAM using ngrok to metasaploit I have some questions about ngrok. The contents of this page are not supported by Mojang AB, the. over 5 years It seems that ngrok does not support UTF-8 coding yet; over 5 years ngrok needs a documented API for third party clients; over 5 years Ngrok sometimes fails on startup if there is not enough entropy just after a system boot. com we will be happy to help. in the background) and without user intervention. in final lab - my ngrok io url is not working 2 years ago by Joe_Scanlon: Catching up with week 2. Please see the full Contributors Graph for our list of contributors. We take care of the rest. Is there an easy fix for that besid. In Grok applications, views work for models: subclasses of grok. MogileFS an open source distributed filesystem. Since we are doing development, our application URL will be localhost, but this URL will not work in this case. This patch allows requests that don't match a host to still be processed. Notebooks have an issue with newer versions of Flask, so force an older version if working in these environments. maybe what you've described is how real world implementations work). I also tried to use ngrok to create a tcp tunnel on port 3389, and it gets created fine, but RDP won't connect to address that ngrok is showing. txt & Is there any equivalent in Windows? I can't seem to figure out a way to do this with the windows version of emacs. It's part of the Golden Shield Project, also called the National Public Security Work Informational Project. NOOK for Windows 10 (Windows), free and safe download. So we know why it failed, how do we fix this? Well ideally we fix the original docker image to not run as root. If you are trying to run a program, it will run the program then close unless you set it not to. In typical applications this is not the case however - views display information that is stored elsewhere. 作者: 回复/查看: 最后发表 [固件讨论] 不要拿迅雷下载,自己NAS分享出来的东西~ New固件讨论] 不要拿迅雷下载,自己NAS分享出来. Working with a potentially larger number of Spring Boot applications in your workspace can turn the Spring Boot dashboard into a crowded place. Protocol the server supports (FTP, SFTP, FTPS, etc. The Ngrok URL is the public address. Buffering helps to optimize performance with slow clients, which can waste proxied server time if the response is passed from NGINX to the client synchronously. ngrok start -config ~/. Spoofing Geo IP for local Development. KingRoot PC is a program that will let you root your Android device just by connecting it to your computer via USB. Good Coding Practice. This is an application. I want to use ngrok to bring this to internet so that other people out there can access to it. Looking at the content of the response can often be useful. Looks easy right no, the first trouble which started was the data not being received on the cloud side. since we are using ngrok, select HTTPS, and enter the secure link is generated in ngrok serve, save it and proceed to next step. A lot of website owners and designers get around this by working on their WordPress sites "offline". ngrok, running on a windows box. For a detailed explanation of how HTTPS prevents a man-in-the-middle from decrypting your traffic, see any standard resource on SSL/TLS, e. If you’ve driven a car, used a credit card, called a company for service, opened an account, flown on a plane, submitted a claim, or performed countless other everyday tasks, chances are you’ve interacted with Pega. Please list exactly what you are doing and what is happening. Marilia Girardi Piva it looks like we were able to reproduce this issue The fix will be available in the next release! Best regards, Eugene. We can typically go from an idea for a bot to having a working prototype in just a matter of days. I can think of no smart reason why your local ip would work and the local loopback would not work, except that when you tried your actual ip the request would go to the network and back again, I presume. I don't use it every day, so I don't know exactly when it stopped working. sys which is the Windows component that handles incoming network requests made using the HTTP protocol, is not allowing the request. That said, however, the most important thing is to go into the experience with a clear picture of what you need and how all the pieces of your Plex setup work together. In this article I will demonstrate how to configure your local development environment to work with the environmental variables set up within your Azure environment in the sample bot previously discussed, Introduction In the previous article we looked at how to create a sample azure bot and then how to configure it in VSTS for continuous integration. A queue is a temporary storage location from which messages can be sent and received reliably, as and when conditions permit. I'm able to connect to the inbound gmail (however it's not actually pulling in any emails ) and I am able to use the php mail() function. How To Create a systemd Service in Linux (CentOS 7) | Creating a systemd service in Linux is much easier than writing init scripts. In this video I am showing a Node Bot Framework Bot, but ngrok will work with any language. SOLVED: Update not working 6/5/18 8:51 am - Setup just hangs - rebooted - just locks up everything - forced setup to close - caused Windows to stop. Not all clients that initiate TLS connections support setting the SNI extension data. Hi everyone, I am facing a strange problem I did not have a few weeks ago before a windows update took place. But before we dive into why that's the case, I want to explain how I support ngrok. 12 - Add support for Visual Studio 2019. How can I terminate it?. Finally, we limit the files we're searching for to images in the current channel (by passing the channel id to the channel parameter and images to type). One connection enables you to integrate with any service in our ecosystem with the tap of a button and at a fraction of the cost. Yes technically it can go in the Subject Alternative Name (SAN) along with any domain names. If the bot isn't running with these settings, you don't need to run the emulator with the settings either. I develop on Windows (don’t judge) and run WAMP. Static IP Address is now a part of the Port Forward Networking Utilities. Build and test Linux and Windows applications and easily share them with others, bundling the code. I know there are methods for stepping through remote code that has been deployed to Azure, but it's not as easy as debugging local code and certainly not as fast. I want to use ngrok to bring this to internet so that other people out there can access to it. Using ngrok is a great way to quickly demo/show your local development to public. If you use Python regularly, you might have come across the wonderful requests library. Upon testing again, I confirmed that it did not work on the local network; I thought it did, so sorry folks! However, the new Fallback IP Address feature was just released, so that resolves this issue. in the background) and without user intervention. Hi every body First time here, first projet on Local by Flywheel I’m writting from France ( so excuse my poor english) Everything was running good until a few days ago I have a problem with the “live link” to show the project This link has worked but now, i have this message "Cette page ne fonctionne pas 7c4ffb1e. Each of the methods below is aimed to be a one-liner that you can copy/paste. Himanshu Thakur. If you don’t install the latest version of the broker, you will get odd errors (because of version compatibility errors) and it will not work. This library is written in ES5, so it will work in older browsers assuming you have the polyfills. But am still going to provision for it here. Plex is a really polished product, and once you get it up and running it’s about as headache free as it gets. Do not take advantage of the relevant technology introduced in this article to do anything that deviates from morality or against the law. pip install flask-ngrok Inside Jupyter / Colab Notebooks. CYBER WORLD The ultimate blog for all of you who want to learn new computer stuff like, cool notepad and hacking tricks, great VBScript, C, C++ examples and many more!. 3)its says server is online and waiting for client. com/public/mz47/ecb. Step 5: Make an MSF Payload. Check everything again (especially if you are using a configuration file(s)), and make sure that everything is typed correctly. This is the third part of ‘Who Am I – A Facebook Game’. How to Remotely Turn On Your PC Over the Internet Chris Hoffman @chrisbhoffman Updated August 10, 2017, 9:29pm EDT If you use remote desktop, remote file access, or other server software, you may leave your computer on at home or work when you leave the house. I know openswan works because when I connect from home network with an internal ip address of 10. Edit the variable value. io, and tries to connect to the dev server directly. I`ll find the Suitable Solution for that. x:xxxx -subdomain=mysubdomain. Such connections are normally independent from, and unrelated to, those established from client to server. - Eugen Oct 31 '17 at 21:34. -For modpacks using Forge 1. Although the program's interface is in Chinese, you won't have to learn the language in order to use it. This will not work for hard coded absolute paths in the database (which is what @leokhoa did note). Download files. Test your signature interactively. Common issues Duplicate events. Problema if naka LTE sim and behind a transparent proxy like most LTE sim sa globe and probably sa smart also. I know the ngrok url and Flask application I am using work because I can receive a payload from Zoho Forms. Ngrok and pretty much any tunneling software should work so long as they create virtualized network adapters on your computer. One at WLAN(WiFi) level 2. ngrok allows you to create tunnels to your machine and give them a. Finding "Next Monday" using MySQL Dates Wed, Dec 2. local executes, the path environmanet variable (or any other environment variable) may not have been set up so it's important to use the program or script's full path. Redis is an open source, BSD licensed, advanced key-value store. The app will not put an icon in the system tray. Serveo was inspired by ngrok and attempts to serve many of the same purposes. If I understand correctly, creating a Twilio Capability Token involves some kind of encryption process that happens exclusively on my own server. It is a long string separated by semicolons. But when i try to connect with ngrok. You can see servers are getting request and post it. Example: i { font-family: fontawesome !important; } Note, it is better to use specific CSS classes in order not to effect site globally. 3) Tick the box for Share this folder and then please make sure the the Share name is correct. How can I terminate it?. 04 Lts? Learn how to uninstall and completely remove the package ngrok-server from Ubuntu 16. io is started when I run the code on terminal (after moving ngrok executable file to /usr/local/bin) ngrok tcp 22 I get. You could possibly lose your job or get reported so try to be professional. If you find that a field in the UI is not listed in the reference page, check our accounting tutorials page for confirmation that it is not supported. Learn how to download, install and start using the Ngrok localhost tunnel tool on Mac OS X. You are in control of the tunnel, and it should work through most corporate firewalls without the need for additional configuration. The code is used for Forms Authentication with OWIN. In this video I am showing a Node Bot Framework Bot, but ngrok will work with any language. Make sure to select the version that corresponds with the mod/modpack you are using otherwise it may not work or could even break your server. Restart the server. 04 has one server block enabled by default. If your browser, computer, and network are all working and the website reports that the page or site is working for them, the 502 Bad Gateway issue could be caused by a network issue that your ISP is responsible for. 4 Special Characters in Queries. This wikiHow teaches you how to host a website on your own home network. One of the coolest features of ASP. f2 Windows 10 I'm building it for android and Ios (unity cloud build) here my code in posting. The current stable version of npm is here. AspNetCore WebHooks. This is also the case with Cumulus Continue reading. I have Filezilla in my exclusion list on my FW, but it still does not work. For example, Apache httpd server. We appreciate it!. Any idea why the batch file (or the shortcut version) just opens a ommand windowbut does not seem to read and execute the contents ?. You'll use a free program called MAMP to do so. how the load should work out ?. We are not responsible for any illegal actions you do with theses files. but I still could not connect, then to see if I can even ping the machine , I enabled the ping , by creating a new Inbound rule , in firewall--> advance settings, , custom rule,ICMPv4, As soon as the ping service enabled, the RDC started working for me. Remember to always register your Functions class into services, if you don’t do that, the depedendency injection will not work properly. com; Use any disposable email service to sign up. ngrok is a great tool for hackathons, demos, and testing oauth. Your network will be analyzed. list file may break or compromise your Kali Linux system. Make sure to find a working method for your hardware! Too bright screens can cause eye strain. One of the coolest features of ASP. So if your adventure map is not working double check you have enabled command blocks. MB has started blocking links generated by ngrok. Twitter has a validation tool but obviously it does not work for localhost url. Download files. Even if you can confirm the proxy hasn't MITM'd the connection you still won't know if there's a proxy based on IP or not. 0 mvc web app which is kind of working (after adding options. Hello, I started the server on my computer, but it is not accessible from a non-local area network. Replay with. so i am not sure what is going on ? why the service bus is not working, and as a result we are not able to debug our remote event receiver? so can i use ngrok. One at WLAN(WiFi) level 2. but I still could not connect, then to see if I can even ping the machine , I enabled the ping , by creating a new Inbound rule , in firewall--> advance settings, , custom rule,ICMPv4, As soon as the ping service enabled, the RDC started working for me. Which command did you use to run ngrok? It should be ngrok http 3000. 3)its says server is online and waiting for client. If you do not have two spare domain names to play with, use dummy names for now and we'll show you later how to configure your local computer to test your configuration. Looks easy right no, the first trouble which started was the data not being received on the cloud side. Just, how do I get my Printer back on line. The ngrok method works by tunneling through either http or https ports 80 & 443. When a comment is added by a user in JIRA, the note gets added by different username in Freshdesk instead of the same one. Any other listed 3rd-party and unofficial repositories within the /etc/apt/sources. Which command did you use to run ngrok? It should be ngrok http 3000. The reason is links in Wordpress are absolute and hard-configured in database, you just need to install the odt-relative-urls plugin and it will work: https://g. json file, then the Chrome extension makes a standard CORS request. If you do not know the values, you can remove those from the locally running bot's configuration file, then run the bot in the Emulator. Also, I am able to receive a payload from Sugar in pipedream (requestbin). yml -config project-config. 记得今年春节前,ngrok. Have tried both versions: compiled by myself and official Digium SILK codec. Using ngrok is a great way to quickly demo/show your local development to public. Is it because the logstash is not able to recognize the fields [fs. A tutorial on how to host a Garry's Mod Server using SteamCMD, completely written from scratch. Beside these changes lot of work has been undertaken to remove as much dependencies on “older” zope. If I understand correctly, creating a Twilio Capability Token involves some kind of encryption process that happens exclusively on my own server. this does not work for HEAD requests, which is a shame, because. Typical tasks for using such processes include logging, system monitoring, scheduling, and user notification. The systems in which you use the certificate may or may not correctly make use of the information (application dependent). Operations on a database are preformed atomically. While ngrok is running, login to the Bot Framework portal and view your bot settings and scroll down to Configuration. To contribute, fork this repo to your own GitHub account. I don't use it every day, so I don't know exactly when it stopped working. NET Web API in Azure App Service and we went through the quick demo of CRUD operation in Kendo Grid which consumes the REST API services that we have created and deployed as Azure Web app. NET 5 MVC 6 – damienbod continues his look at localisation in ASP. Those cheap "charging" cables from eBay are a disaster waiting to happen. The Web API implementation does supports a lot of features from the standard, but not all. ngrok is a such an application to expose localhost URLs to public URLs accessible over the internet. Download and run ngrok using command ngrok. Choose if you want to protect the tunnel with your login credentials at the security section. The others do not give this confidence (serveo). com/public/mz47/ecb. If you are using Windows 10 you don’t need to setup the environment variable. Is there a reason why? 2 years ago by djwillia-Oracle: MOOC: Welcome message when starting the dialog 1 year ago. 01-16-2019: Welcome to the new Shopify Community! If you were a member of the Ecommerce University forums please register again using the same email address which will link your account to your Ecommerce University post history. 1 applications. Bitbucket cloud Webhooks for Jenkins giving 500 Status Code. You can see servers are getting request and post it. Explore 21 apps like ngrok, all suggested and ranked by the AlternativeTo user community. This means if you've configured a webhook with your ngrok URL, you will need to update. Using ngrok to expose MusicBox webpage? Pi MusicBox traffic but it appears as though Spotify search does not work when this is done. Or we can convert the localhost URLs to public URL. ifnames=0 biosdevname=0" to the end of cmdline. I want to use ngrok to bring this to internet so that other people out there can access to it. Please and thank you! Clarity: My Local IP lets me connect to my server, but I can't figure out how to allow friends access. With some Ngrok. This can make it difficult, if not impossible, to get your entry form to submit successfully. eval has no man page because it is not a separate external command, but rather a shell built-in, meaning a command internal to and known only by the shell (bash). the ones using PHP. --/prog/ rules: 1. This week Lju Lazarevic and Andrea Santurbano show us how to do event driven graph analytics using Neo4j and Apache Kafka, and we have the Spring Release of the APOC library. The primary advantage of Serveo over ngrok is the use of your existing SSH client, so there's no client application to install. How can I install wordpress locally on Windows 10? Local by Flywheel will not work if you have Hyper-V enabled on Windows 10. Today we are releasing the first preview of EF Core 2. He was using it fine 6 weeks ago but downloaded something and has not worked since. pip install flask-ngrok Inside Jupyter / Colab Notebooks. By contrast, sockets and other network protocols assume that direct connections always exist. We will use Standard PHP Library (SPL) to tackle the. Popular Alternatives to ngrok for Linux, Mac, Windows, Android, Web and more. 115:8063正常,但是通过动态公网ip访问此端口不能成功,重复试了好多遍还是不行,最后偶然电脑连到. Download the file for your platform. Full support 5. A tutorial on how to host a Garry's Mod Server using SteamCMD, completely written from scratch. To test whether our service is working or not. The latest and greates updates and announcements from Ionic. Check everything again (especially if you are using a configuration file(s)), and make sure that everything is typed correctly. Right-click the original EXE file (not the copy you made) and choose “Open using Resource Hacker. One final thing; if this fails and you can’t work out why, some ngrok investigation will show you that canned is extremely liberal and sharing – it adds CORS headers all over the place to accept the incoming requests from Alexa. At least it is the situation in CN. 2 Quickstart. But there is just one problem with this method – moving your completed masterpiece online. > ngrok can not possibly be easier than port forwarding. Leave the subdomain blank to auto generate, or pick your own. json file, then the Chrome extension makes a standard CORS request. How to Solve Hamachi Not Working in Windows 10 Set Up Hamachi! (Obsolete As of 2. In the Pick a publish target dialog, ensure App Service is selected on the left and Create New is selected on the right. I entered my username and password with azim58 and somepassword. On our addon folder, I run ‘npm install’ and then ‘npm st. When I take that json formatted payload from pipedream and send it to my Flask application using Postman, I am able to access the data. Download and run ngrok using command ngrok. We will use Standard PHP Library (SPL) to tackle the. Create Combined Network (if your network is not already configured this way). NOTE: Teams does not work nor render things exactly like the Bot Emulator, but it is a quick way to see if your bot is running and functioning correctly. That said, however, the most important thing is to go into the experience with a clear picture of what you need and how all the pieces of your Plex setup work together. If you want to know exactly what it takes to hack valid credit cards via different methods, then I will be posting some tutorials on those methods soon, but if you dont want to put in the effort to learn how to hack your own credit card details and would rather just buy them from a genuine hacker/seller online then u need to know exactly where. Come back after you are sure that ngrok is working. Dockerizing a Cesium node. Not working if the https is handled by a proxy like Cloudflare, since the server listens on port 80 and not 443. Hello, I started the server on my computer, but it is not accessible from a non-local area network. Most of the time it should be safe to run the 32-bit version on 64-bit Windows but in some circumstances you may find that it doesn't work and you must use the 64-bit version. When you installed Resource Hacker, it added an option to the context menu you get when you right-click files. However, very often, for no apparent. NOOK for Windows 10 latest version: A better experience than Amazon can muster. For example, in Bash, I can do this: emacs foo. Please note that from inside your LAN you will not beable to access your server using its public IP address (WAN IP onthe router, e. ngrok is a tunneling, reverse proxy that establishes secure tunnels from a public endpoint to a locally running network service while capturing all traffic for inspection and replay. Make sure your ngrok server is working and Python script also running otherwise it will not work. and fail, even if a set up a public key does not work, for some reason the configuration change when try to connect with a host different to localhost. Going through a process of packaging and deploying your work to a public server can be a huge drain on productivity. You can use the Bot Framework to build and connect bots to interact with your users in apps (or communication channels) such as your website, Skype, Facebook Messenger, and Office 365 mail. Issues 160. Redis is written in C. The fact-checkers, whose work is more and more important for those who prefer facts over lies, police the line between fact and falsehood on a day-to-day basis, and do a great job. Today, my small contribution is to pass along a very good overview that reflects on one of Trump’s favorite overarching falsehoods. Namely: Trump describes an America in which everything was going down the tubes under  Obama, which is why we needed Trump to make America great again. And he claims that this project has come to fruition, with America setting records for prosperity under his leadership and guidance. “Obama bad; Trump good” is pretty much his analysis in all areas and measurement of U.S. activity, especially economically. Even if this were true, it would reflect poorly on Trump’s character, but it has the added problem of being false, a big lie made up of many small ones. Personally, I don’t assume that all economic measurements directly reflect the leadership of whoever occupies the Oval Office, nor am I smart enough to figure out what causes what in the economy. But the idea that presidents get the credit or the blame for the economy during their tenure is a political fact of life. Trump, in his adorable, immodest mendacity, not only claims credit for everything good that happens in the economy, but tells people, literally and specifically, that they have to vote for him even if they hate him, because without his guidance, their 401(k) accounts “will go down the tubes.” That would be offensive even if it were true, but it is utterly false. The stock market has been on a 10-year run of steady gains that began in 2009, the year Barack Obama was inaugurated. But why would anyone care about that? It’s only an unarguable, stubborn fact. Still, speaking of facts, there are so many measurements and indicators of how the economy is doing, that those not committed to an honest investigation can find evidence for whatever they want to believe. Trump and his most committed followers want to believe that everything was terrible under Barack Obama and great under Trump. That’s baloney. Anyone who believes that believes something false. And a series of charts and graphs published Monday in the Washington Post and explained by Economics Correspondent Heather Long provides the data that tells the tale. The details are complicated. Click through to the link above and you’ll learn much. But the overview is pretty simply this: The U.S. economy had a major meltdown in the last year of the George W. Bush presidency. Again, I’m not smart enough to know how much of this was Bush’s “fault.” But he had been in office for six years when the trouble started. So, if it’s ever reasonable to hold a president accountable for the performance of the economy, the timeline is bad for Bush. GDP growth went negative. Job growth fell sharply and then went negative. Median household income shrank. The Dow Jones Industrial Average dropped by more than 5,000 points! U.S. manufacturing output plunged, as did average home values, as did average hourly wages, as did measures of consumer confidence and most other indicators of economic health. (Backup for that is contained in the Post piece I linked to above.) Barack Obama inherited that mess of falling numbers, which continued during his first year in office, 2009, as he put in place policies designed to turn it around. By 2010, Obama’s second year, pretty much all of the negative numbers had turned positive. By the time Obama was up for reelection in 2012, all of them were headed in the right direction, which is certainly among the reasons voters gave him a second term by a solid (not landslide) margin. Basically, all of those good numbers continued throughout the second Obama term. The U.S. GDP, probably the single best measure of how the economy is doing, grew by 2.9 percent in 2015, which was Obama’s seventh year in office and was the best GDP growth number since before the crash of the late Bush years. GDP growth slowed to 1.6 percent in 2016, which may have been among the indicators that supported Trump’s campaign-year argument that everything was going to hell and only he could fix it. During the first year of Trump, GDP growth grew to 2.4 percent, which is decent but not great and anyway, a reasonable person would acknowledge that — to the degree that economic performance is to the credit or blame of the president — the performance in the first year of a new president is a mixture of the old and new policies. In Trump’s second year, 2018, the GDP grew 2.9 percent, equaling Obama’s best year, and so far in 2019, the growth rate has fallen to 2.1 percent, a mediocre number and a decline for which Trump presumably accepts no responsibility and blames either Nancy Pelosi, Ilhan Omar or, if he can swing it, Barack Obama. I suppose it’s natural for a president to want to take credit for everything good that happens on his (or someday her) watch, but not the blame for anything bad. Trump is more blatant about this than most. If we judge by his bad but remarkably steady approval ratings (today, according to the average maintained by 538.com, it’s 41.9 approval/ 53.7 disapproval) the pretty-good economy is not winning him new supporters, nor is his constant exaggeration of his accomplishments costing him many old ones). I already offered it above, but the full Washington Post workup of these numbers, and commentary/explanation by economics correspondent Heather Long, are here. On a related matter, if you care about what used to be called fiscal conservatism, which is the belief that federal debt and deficit matter, here’s a New York Times analysis, based on Congressional Budget Office data, suggesting that the annual budget deficit (that’s the amount the government borrows every year reflecting that amount by which federal spending exceeds revenues) which fell steadily during the Obama years, from a peak of $1.4 trillion at the beginning of the Obama administration, to $585 billion in 2016 (Obama’s last year in office), will be back up to $960 billion this fiscal year, and back over $1 trillion in 2020. (Here’s the New York Times piece detailing those numbers.) Trump is currently floating various tax cuts for the rich and the poor that will presumably worsen those projections, if passed. As the Times piece reported: